« What went wrong? Spurs 1 Man City 5

thfc1882.com

Spurs blog

What now for Spurs midfield?

9 Comments »

As 11pm came on Wednesday there was a palpable sigh of relief from many Spurs fans. Finally all the press speculation about who was on their way in and out of the club could be put to bed and now the focus would be on the football. At least until December, just before the next window opened. Surely?

No. Not 48 hours into September, The Evening Standard – a publication that has had issues with Spurs for years now – was touting the Modric to Chelsea move for January’s window. This is just another example of certain sectors of the press who seem to have a vested interest in Modric moving to West London. They must all be on a cut of the deal. Or fear Abramovich’s ‘contacts’ from his homeland.

Whatever the media’s motivation, one things for sure, they aren’t making life easy for their favorite manager, Harry Redknapp. This Modric situation will push the famed man-manager to his very limits. It’s going to be Redknapp’s job to make sure there are no repeats of the ‘my heads not right’ situation before the United and City games. While Modric may not be terribly popular with Spurs fans right now, it would take a very short sighted person to believe that the team is better without him (if he’s on form). Where else is the creativity going to come from? Especially with Rafa Van der Vaart sidelined with injury.

Scott Parker may bring battling qualities and much needed character to Spurs midfield he’s not exactly a creative genius like the Croatian. Niko Kranjcar is fine in the middle against Hearts but Premier League opposition is an entirely different prospect, not one that any Spurs fan will look forward to with any relish after Sunday. One man who has shown potential forever is Tom Huddlestone. With superb technique and ability to hit a pass off either foot with deadly accuracy, he’s long been hailed the spiritual successor to Glenn Hoddle. Unfortunately his athletic abilities are equal to Andy Reid rather than Hod – who was hardly famed for his physicality -  and his injury lay offs are always followed by long searches for match sharpness. Once he returns from injury Sandro will look to take his game to the next level, he though again, isn’t a creative force. Whilst it would be great to dream that youth may get it’s chance, in reality it’s unlikely that Redknapp will risk it other than in the cup competitions. Therefore with Parker’s arrival, Jake Livermore’s impressive start will be slowed down, that much is made clear by the fact he was offered to West Ham in a loan deal. Another youngster who will hopefully play in the cup competitions is Tom Carroll. Even played out of position in the second leg against Hearts, he showed that he already has a good range of passing and the vision to go with it.

If Redknapp is unable to work his magic on Modric then Spurs midfield will be severely lacking in it’s spark and ability to carve out openings for an Emmanuel Adebayor led strikeforce. This will lead to more responsibility for the wide players. Gareth Bale looked to be hitting his stride in pre season but like many of the team didn’t do himself justice in the first two Premier League games. On the other wing, there are even more concerns, Aaron Lennon has a groin injury but that aside has been woeful at the start of the season. Unlike the left with Andros Townsend, Steven Pienaar and even Niko Kranjcar there isn’t a lot of back up for Aaron. Unless Giovanni Dos Santos is finally going to be given a chance. It seems beyond belief – Redknapp is clearly not a fan despite the Mexicans abilities – but is the only viable option unless Iago Falque really outdoes himself.  Dos Santos is better suited to playing just off the striker and using him on the right could lead to similar problems suffered when Van der Vaart is deployed there. Both players are more comfortable drifting in onto their left foot and are prone to wander, leaving the right hand side woefully exposed.

If Redknapp is forced to use a solid, workmanlike central pairing then he risks his team becoming one dimensional and easy to nullify. As seen repeatedly in the Premier League last year, Gareth Bale can be marked out of games, particularly if opposition wingers are disciplined, track back and help their full back. Spurs Welsh wing wizard needs to really work on his game this year if he’s to be the main man. He can do it, he’s shown he has the skills, he just needs to develop his footballing intelligence and realise when his trademark ‘push the ball past the man and sprint’ trick is going to work and when he needs to try something different. If teams are able to keep Spurs wing threat quiet then it will most likely result in repeated Dawson ‘Hollywood balls’ punted at Adebayor’s head. Having watched that happen every time Crouch played over the past couple of seasons, it really isn’t what Spurs fans want to see and can be just as easily snubbed out as a threat by marking the men looking for the knock downs.

All this brings us back to Redknapp and Modric and finding a way to motivate the Croat playmaker to perform while wearing the ‘chicken badge’. It’s clear that Modric wants away but he must now accept that he’s a Spurs player until January at least and will be expected to play his part or rot in Spurs non-existent reserves. Harry Redknapp may even use the Chelsea move as a motivating tool, telling him that if he’s not playing or playing poorly then Chelsea may drop their interest.

All of this will surely challenge Redknapp to the fullest, he’s already said it’s been the toughest pre-season he’s ever had – of course no mention of how tough it’s been for the club – and this could well be his hardest season in football. Obviously the defeats against the best two teams in the country need to be taken in perspective but even so, confidence appears low and it’s crucial that the team that takes the field are all convinced that their team mates are all on the same page. Redknapp has repeatedly said what a good professional Modric is, only to then destroy that image by revealing Luka’s state of mind to the press. He now needs to turn it back around and get Modric on the pitch, performing to his best. If he can do that, Spurs can get themselves into a position to challenge for the top four and then if Modric is still wanted by Chelsea, targets can be identified that can take his place for what will be a fraction of any fee received for Modric.

Just as vital as Redknapp getting Modric on the pitch in the right mindset is the Spurs faithful getting behind the manager and team. Modric is not going to be everyone’s favourite player but whilst he’s in Lilywhite needs to be supported, even if it’s only for a few more months. Those months could be crucial in shaping Spurs, not just this season but for many to come.

COYS

Stuart Watts ( @Studub on Twitter )

 

 

Related posts:

  1. Match Report: Tottenham Hotspur 1-0 Sunderland
  2. Match Report: Blackburn Rovers 1-2 Spurs
  3. Match Report: Brighton 2 Spurs 3
  4. Match Preview: Spurs v Arsenal
  5. Match Preview: Stoke v Tottenham Hotspur

9 Responses

its about time the manager took a tough stance with modric and tell him he’s part of a team and to get on with to or theres a nice comfy seat in the west stand for him … then he will get the message I’m sure

  • I want to see the following midfield/attack:

    Parker Huddlestone
    Giovani Modric Bale
    Adebayor

    Note Gio keeps VDVs space warm, Hudd same for Sandro…

  • I think it will be more important for Spurs if Harry will be able to motivate Adebayor.
    If Adebayoris is in his proper form, Spurs can win a game even without Modric.

  • HR needs to sort Modric in the short term but I think it Levy’s problem to settle Modric in the long term and it’s got to be more money, I’m sure Levy promised something to get a player of Modric’s standard to sign a 5 year contract for only 40k a week when we’re paying players half his class nearly twice as much.

  • Thanks for the comments so far. I didn’t bother mentioning a 4231 or anything else because I don’t think it’ll happen.
    @loanX – sigh….Of course we can win without Modric, I haven’t said that we can’t, but with our current squad he is the playmaker and the team will need to change if he’s not playing. If you can’t see that you are one of the shortsighted I mentioned in the article.

    COYS

  • Studub,

    Whatever way you look at it, we have a pretty strong midfield.

    I had also toyed with the 4231 idea, but don’t think HR will consider that. I think our season is really resting on the managers shoulder, if he can come up with plan B even a plan C, we could win at least 5 more games than last season.

    I think (could of been a dream) I read a stat from last season that we had one of the worst goal to chances ratios, which hopefully Ade can improve.

    I’m also quite sure we had a better win ratio when Modric wasn’t in the team.

    Anyway, good stuff!!

  • Good stuff Stu and it is indeed frustrating that no sooner has the window slammed shut journo’s still bang on about it”Modric”.He has to and i feel will settle down now and crack on and play a major part in CM,4-2-3-1 has to be the way forward with Parker&Sandro sat infront of the back four thus giving Modric,Bale,Dos Santos”if without VdV and Lennon” the freedom to attack,if Dos Santos brings his Mexico form to the Lane then he will be like a new signing for me but and its a massive BUT will Redknapp again under use him.Adebayor i feel will be easy to handle in his season with us 1,because he has a massive point to prove and 2,he is nearing the final stages of his City contract”a even bigger incentive”to crack on,for those reasons i think Adebayor will be massive for us this season.My only concern is Redknapp himself,surely he has to see the 4-2-3-1 formation will be great with the players he has at his disposal,Citeh played that way at the Lane with Barry&Toure sat and giving Nasri,Silva”class player”and Aguero the licence to run riot,will be interesting to see what Redknapp decides to do,probably not that i sadly feel.

  • Everything said there is spot on we’ll ignore the one Harry dig you couldn’t resist, but what I would say to @kevski07 is that the 4 2 3 1 formation is not the way forward yet, Sandro is out for at least another 6 weeks which means we have to stick to 442 for now. I like Dos Santos but he can only play as second striker and Adebayor is the only one. He’s not strong enough physically for the PL .
    With Lennon injured I would try him down the right mainly because there’s no one else Niko is useless there. So Bale Modric Parker and ? For the next 2 months and ? Can only be Lennon when fit, the fact he has no competition is poor,he’s stood still so far this season and his wimpiness to come off at any opportunity really sucks……
    Modric doesn’t want to be with us and we don’t want him well most of us dont but we’re stuck with him for the next 5 months so we have to put up with each other and that means we as fans have to support him and he as a player has to man up and get back to what he was doing last season and score the odd goal also……
    As Stu says Bale has been found out and needs to improve his game judging his first two but he showed signs against Montenegro that he can play on the right so maybe H will play him there with Niko on the left……we criticised H for doing it but it worked better for Wales so it’s an idea…..

  • Great Article Stu, the one i’ve been waiting for. I’ll admit that I didn’t really watch Scott Parker so I can’t really comment on him. With Luka, we can only but hope that he’ll get his head down and do the job. I’d really love for HR to tell our players to look up at times because I’m sure we can all see when a man is open and watch whoever has the ball, turn in the other direction or pass back. Thats something I can see Thud doing provided that he has enough time on the ball which at the moment is a tad frustrating that he expects so much time. Niko can run a game, just not in the fashion that Modric can because I’ve noticed that if he’s first touch is off, he’ll struggle the entire match.
    I know this was about midfield but why on earth do we play 1 up front against “bigger” teams when our strongest formation is a 4 4 2. I can’t understand how if we play with one up front, any any crosses come in, its our one striker against 2 defenders. I really thought Dos Santos was on his way, we all saw how well he plays for Mexico who doesn’t really have a set formation but they have fluidity, so i’m not sure he could help. Provided that 62mins into the match our central midfielders don’t run out of creativity, we should be able to cope.

    Great article again Stu.
    2Strikers are better than 1

  • Leave a Reply