I didn’t write a match preview for yesterday’s FA Cup forth round tie at Fulham mainly because I had a bad feeling about it. I’m not being Mr I Told You So after the event and I didn’t for one second think we’d get our asses handed to us in the manner we did but I thought it would be a tricky tie, won by the odd goal in 3.
Possibly the worse performance under Redknapp? Maybe worse than any Ramos game? The worse since Gerry Francis? These are all statements I’ve seen bandied about since the final whistle and I can’t really disagree with any of them. However, it’s not the first time this season we’ve played like that. Young Boys and Inter away were exactly the same, the only difference was managing to score some goals after the game was lost that papered over gaps larger than the one’s we had running through the entire side at Craven Cottage.
Where to start?
- The entire team was shocking
- The formation was terrible
- Individual errors cost us early on
With the exception of a few players, Bale and Palacios being the main ones it was a full strength team. I watched a Spurs game on ESPN for the first time and was amazed when they stated Corluka was in fact Sandro and then put our starting XI into a line up which looked like this:
Gomes
Hutton Dawson Bassong Ekotto
Sandro
Pienaar Modric Lennon
Defoe van der Vaart
As much as I hate Sky sometimes at least they’re not as stupid to make simple mistakes like that. ESPN must be the ITV of the satellite stations. It was clear to everyone with those players it would be our normal 4-4-1-1 with Pienaar replacing Bale, Lennon in his normal right position and Sandro covering the Palacios role. How pathetic of them not to do their research properly. Right?
Then Redknapp was interviewed before the game, in the tunnel not on the pitch, which for reasons known only to EPSN is where they present the show from. He confirmed there would be a change in formation, but surely it wouldn’t be the same one the TV channel had so mysteriously plucked out of thin air? I was wrong, it was exactly how ESPN had covered it. I hung my head in shame and then proceeded to work out exactly what was going on.
No fluidity, no ball retention, no width, players looking lost in positions alien to them. In all fairness ESPN did get it slightly wrong because Modric didn’t get anywhere near as advanced as they suggested he would. In fact we played a 4-2-3-1 formation with both Sandro and Modric sitting deep. What it meant was we had absolutely no width, much like we did against Newcastle and Fulham found it very easy to deal with. Any width we did have came from Lennon and Pienaar who preferred to cut inside than run down the line, having been told to play on the opposite side to their preferred position. Genius.
Anyway, so the formation was abysmal and not for the first time this season (or last) we’ve been found out tactically. What happened to the simple days of putting players in their natural positions and telling them to go out there and express themselves? More importantly for the short term future, what’s happened to the saying, learn from your mistakes? At the moment we’re making the same one’s time and time again. Everton, Charlton, United and now Fulham to name just the most recent formation and tactical errors. Some have cost us and some haven’t.
Alterations didn’t occur until the second half and the removal of Sandro for Gallas once Dawson saw red was a strange one. Removing Pienaar or Lennon would’ve made much more sense instead of leaving us with no defensive minded midfielder. Remove Pienaar, put Lennon on the right and vdV on the left would’ve left us with a 4-4-1 and a much more balanced team rather than a midfield of offensive minded players who struggled to win the ball back, and left the defence exposed constantly. A puzzler from Redknapp that one. By the time he sent Crouch on for Defoe he’d already given up. At that point the brilliant away support this club of ours has should’ve got up and walked out before Putney Bridge tube station got too busy. If only the players and management showed the same belief and determination of those fans, singing to the last whistle.
The one thing any manager or coach can be blamed for though is individual errors. While the formation didn’t give us the best chance of winning the game, the two individual errors by the normally reliable Dawson broke us early on. Should he have received a red card for his second error and eventual tackle in the box? I don’t think so, but as I believe Phil Dowd is the best referee there is in the country I don’t think he’s to blame. Everyone makes mistakes and he was definitely pulled back. Bassong continued the individual errors later on for the 3rd and 4th goals but without those error’s we would’ve still lost the game of which I have no doubt.
I can’t think of any positives from it and not one player was on his game. In fact, there haven’t been many positives to take from the last few weeks. Coincidentally since the Beckham circus came to town. Obviously that’s just coincidental but while footballers are grown men we all know how precious they can be at times. Who’s to say van der Vaarts drop in form isn’t down to him not being the number one attraction at the training ground any more? All conjecture and probable bollocks. Much like the soon to close transfer window.
Congratulations to Fulham, who deserved the win, set up correctly and took advantage of another off day at the office from Spurs. Let’s hope these off days don’t become as regular as they have been of late or not only can we kiss goodbye to the top 4, we might be saying goodbye to the top 5.







Spurs News 24/7




